By Bianca Mercedes Lee
The most difficult part of this review will be my attempt to condense all of my feelings into a few paragraphs. 2019 is indeed a very exciting year for anime and I have found myself spending longer intimate nights with Crunchyroll, rather than Netflix (I still love you Netflix). This year gave us the second season of One Punch Man, the new Code Geass movie, a refreshing take on stop-motion anime with Rilakkuma and Kaoru and the star of this review, The Rising of the Shield Hero.
A poster of three charatcers from the Rising of the Shield Hero anime, Naofumi, Raphtalia, and Filo. Image from Netflix South Africa.
The Rising of the Shield Hero transports you into a new world from the first episode. No really, the protagonist is sucked out of modern Japan and into another world within the first few minutes – this anime gets straight to the point. Iwatoni Naofumi (Kaito Ishikawa), a content college student, is summoned as one of the Four Cardinal Heroes to another world, bound by a legend to protect this world from the catastrophic waves that plague it. The four heroes are the Spear Hero, Bow Hero, Sword Hero and Shield Hero – the Shield Hero being the only hero without a weapon. Naofumi, unfortunately, finds himself with a shield permanently strapped to his arm and with no other fighter wanting to join his party. Eventually, a beautiful heroine, Malty (Maaya Uchida), joins him as his only ally. The conniving Malty falsely accuses Naofumi of rape and Naofumi is condemned as a criminal and an outcast.
There is an immediate change in Naofumi’s character as distrust becomes his second shield. In his desperation to exact revenge on the nation that betrayed him, he purchases a sickly demi-human slave child, Raphtalia (Asami Seto). Instead of trying to prove his innocence and bring dignity back to his name, Naofumi realises that with a tarnished name he is free to do as he pleases because he no longer has anything to lose. He can be a hero without the pressure of hero etiquette. What we find is a deeply flawed and selfish hero who is also rational, just and protective of those who believe in him. Because we expect so little of Naofumi, his strength and moments of generosity and so much more powerful. At the other end of the see-saw, the other three heroes are worshipped and become naively confident in their abilities. Each time they fail, their failure is magnified by the fact that they have to be rescued by the ridiculed Shield Hero.
A picture from The Rising of the Shield Hero Anime of the character Raphtalia, left, looking over at the Bow Hero, Itsuki Kawasumi, right. Image from Rotten Tomatoes.
I mostly found myself grappling with the way the anime treats womxn. Raphtalia and Filo the filolial (Rina Hidaka) act as Naofumi’s swords. He relies on them to gain experience and level up but both of them are initially portrayed as tools. Raphtalia is a slave, is freed, and chooses to be a slave to Naofumi again. Raphtalia and Filo devote their lives to the Shield Hero but are also sexualised by other characters throughout the anime. The nation itself is a matrilineal monarchy and yet most of the rulers in the anime are men. I feel that the show could have taken advantage of more opportunities to create a stronger feminist experience. It provides you with a small taste but it just is not enough to satisfy our deep hunger for feminism.
A close up of Naofumi Iwatani, the Shield Hero. Image from Rotten Tomatoes.
That aside, the anime is very addictive. It plays with various themes from different RPGs and blends it so seamlessly into a storyline that you start expecting to see a status bar in the corner of your eye after you stop watching. There are so many villains, flawed heroes and likeable characters to keep you entertained. The show is bursting with themes from rape culture, balance, and corrupted hierarchies to friendship, trust and so much more. It sounds overwhelming but trust me, it is not. The anime is well-paced which is important in character development and theme closure. The Rising of the Shield Hero does this pretty spectacularly.
This anime is every nerdy thing you love in a convenient 9 hours of watch-time. You could watch all of these episodes after each other and it will not even count as a binge. And yes, that is me saying you should definitely watch every episode. I will not hide my love for this incredible anime which I am putting in my list of all-time favourites. It is one of those anime shows that filter into your own life and you take the experience with you on your journey. Whether you see this show as a greater analogy for something more meaningful or just an enjoyable, action-packed gift to the eye, it will resonate with you exactly in the way you want it to.
© 2025 Cape Nerd Collective. All rights reserved.
Site designed by Dani Petersen and Luther de Lange